New Star Trek leaves me missing Shatner

AFTER enthusiastic badgering from my friends, I saw the new Star Trek trailer this week.

And … well, let’s just say that I hope JJ Abrams is keeping his powder dry (and drops the car bit).
That’s not to say it wasn’t good – it was – but I can’t help feel that we deserved more.
That goes for one bit of it in particular – the Kirk, Spock, McCoy bit.
For me Kirk is the key because William Shatner’s performance was so distinctive. I’ve seen the pictures and heard the interviews but I still need convincing that Chris Pine can pull it off.
He’s going up against William Shatner for god’s sake! The Shat! Mr Tambourine Man! A living legend who has defied interesting cadence choices to build a career spanning five decades.

No matter what you think of him as a man, he is Captain Kirk and was the centre point of the show and the films. That’s a crucial burden to carry for someone who looks like 90210 would be too much for him.

Spock – because of the character’s nature – would be easier to play but seems at risk of becoming Sylar lite given the footage in the trailer, while McCoy – Bones, the classic hand-wringer – is virtually invisible.
As proved over 70-odd episodes and the films, Shatner had such wonderful chemistry with De Forest Kelley and Leonard Nimoy that when it worked, it really was lightning in a bottle. (That’s despite Shatner being the type of guy who would crap on the last piece of pizza, just so no-one else could have it, allegedly)
Spock was logic, McCoy was heart and Kirk was action – making a decision and charging in like the glory-hogging, alien beauty kissing, strange … talking … and … singing … swine he was.
Obviously the current crew of the Enterprise are just starting their voyages together, but I have been burned with too many films in the past to rave over them.
I want to be queueing outside the cinema on day one of its release, I want to be cheering at the end, I want to have faith – but I don’t yet.
Prove me wrong JJ.

One thought on “New Star Trek leaves me missing Shatner

  • Alison Gow


    I hate to say it but on the strength of what I’ve seen you’re going to be one angry blogger by the end of the film. Roll on Watchmen!

Tell me what you think